Toggle Content Toggle Content

Article Rating

Average Score: 3
Votes: 4


Please take a second and vote for this article:

Excellent
Very Good
Good
Regular
Bad

Donate

 0%

Social Bookmarking


Poll

Hugo Chavez is:




Results :: Polls

Votes: 19
Comments: 1

Chomsky's Ron Paul Comments *CONFIRMED*

Saturday, December 08, 2007 (09:16:07)
Some Ron Paul supporters have been saying that these comments attributed to Chomsky are fake or a hoax. I think znet is generally regarded as reputable source in this respect, but Chomsky seems to have enough problems with misrepresentation, so I wanted to be absolutely sure. I e-mailed Prof. Chomsky to see if he could officially confirm whether the comments are authentic:

Hello Prof. Chomsky,
Some comments regarding Republican Presidential Candidate Ron Paul that have been attributed to you are circulating the internet. They are posted on numerous websites, but no one seems to be able to find an official source. I've included them at the bottom of this e-mail. Can you confirm if these are you're statements? I thought they were, but some Ron Paul supporters are saying it's a fake or a hoax. Is it OK if I post your response to this on my website, AnarchismToday.org? Thanks for your time.

Response:

Write an awful lot of letters, maybe 6-7 hours a day (usually night), so can't be sure, but it looks like a response of mine to questions raised on a Znet forum. Original is presumably there, but I suspect it is the same. I don't know how Znet deals with re-posting, but I'd personally have no objections.

Noam Chomsky

15 comments

The comments are owned by the poster. We aren't responsible for their content.
Threshold
Anonymous

1. Re: Chomsky's Ron Paul Comments *CONFIRMED*

I don't understand why there was controversy over why these comments had to be confirmed or not. If it was or was not him saying these things they are wrong. His answers in the article imply that ron paul is not a reasonable or credible man, which, from studying his history and what he stands for and why, he very much is.

And, just to let everyone know, Ron Paul is not running for president...the 'people' are running for president 'through' Ron Paul and 'thats' the truth!


Re: Chomsky's Ron Paul Comments *CONFIRMED* by personman on Saturday, December 08

Re: Chomsky's Ron Paul Comments *CONFIRMED* by Anonymous on Saturday, December 08

Re: Chomsky's Ron Paul Comments *CONFIRMED* by personman on Thursday, December 13

Re: Chomsky's Ron Paul Comments *CONFIRMED* by Anonymous on Sunday, December 16

Re: Chomsky's Ron Paul Comments *CONFIRMED* by Anonymous on Saturday, December 22

Re: Chomsky's Ron Paul Comments *CONFIRMED* by Anonymous on Sunday, December 30

Re: Chomsky's Ron Paul Comments *CONFIRMED* by personman on Wednesday, January 02

Re: Chomsky's Ron Paul Comments *CONFIRMED* by Anonymous on Tuesday, January 29

Re: Chomsky's Ron Paul Comments *CONFIRMED* by Anonymous on Sunday, January 13

Re: Mischarecterization of Chomsky's comments by Anonymous on Tuesday, January 29

Anonymous

2. Mischarecterization of Chomsky's comments.

Chomsky's comments do not imply that Ron Paul as a man is not reasonable or credible; rather they imply that Noam believes Paul's ideas to be unreasonable and their enacting undesirable. Many individuals' confusion I believe has its origins in their lack of differentiation between libertarianism (specifically libertarian socialism, or Anarchism, the ideas of which Chomsky is sympathetic towards) and the (hyper-capitalist) Libertarian Party of Ron Paul; when people say "libertarian" outside the U.S.A., it doesn't mean what it seems to mean to many Americans.


Re: Mischarecterization of Chomsky's comments. by Anonymous on Monday, February 04

Anonymous

3. Re: Chomsky's Ron Paul Comments *CONFIRMED*

Good resource and very useful info. Thank you very much!

http://rapid4me.com


Anonymous

4. Re: Chomsky's Ron Paul Comments *CONFIRMED*



Post Comment

Your Name: Anonymous [ Login/New User ]

Bold: Italic: Underline:    Left to Right: Right to Left:    URL: Email:
Quote: Code: PHP:    Horizontal Rule:    Marque text to down: Marque text to up: Marque text to left: Marque text to right:
Image:    Insert flash file: Insert video file:      
  
  
NeutralTwisted EvilMr. GreenShocked
SmileArrowCoolEmbarassed
RazzEvil or Very MadRolling EyesVery Happy
IdeaWinkConfusedMad
Crying or Very sadLaughingSurprisedSad
Security Code: Security Code
Type Code: